← Back to the journal

Planning & quotes

Can you keep an existing skylight when replacing a steel roof?

Keeping the skylight and keeping its old flashing are two different decisions. Ask for separate answers before the roof sheets are ordered.

View from a kitchen through a rectangular skylight with a deep white reveal and branches visible outside
AI-generated illustration, not a customer project or an identified skylight model.

A working window answers only half the question

Suppose you want to keep the daylight over your kitchen. The skylight opens smoothly and the ceiling looks dry. Can the roofer leave it in place? Possibly. Ask for two separate findings: whether the window itself is fit to retain, and how the new roof will shed water around its frame. A quote that simply says “retain skylight” doesn't tell you who will do the second job.

Identify the unit before comparing prices

Start indoors. An old invoice or installation booklet may identify the manufacturer, model and size. If the unit is a VELUX, its New Zealand product identification guide explains what the frame label records and how its location varies. Some identifiers are on the exterior. If you can't read yours from a safe position, let the installer check it; don't climb onto the roof or balance on a kitchen bench.

Send the roofer a room photo and whatever records you have. Say whether the window opens, whether you want to keep an existing blind, and whether you have noticed staining after rain. These details help the installer prepare; a photo of a stain alone doesn't establish where water entered.

Match the flashing to the new roof, not just the old window

Flashing is the shaped material that takes water around the skylight and back onto the roof. VELUX's flashing guide distinguishes kits for different roof coverings. Its VS manual skylight data sheet, for example, lists an EDW kit for certain profiled roofs but excludes concealed-clip profiles. “Suitable for metal roofing” is not enough information to order a kit.

Ask the installer to record the existing model, proposed sheet profile and roof pitch, then identify the detail that works for that combination. If a detail must be made for the job, ask who will specify it and who will install it. Our guide to flashing quotes explains how to record that responsibility.

Compare two quotes for the same finished room

One price may cover retaining the unit and renewing its flashing. Another may cover a new window but stop at the frame, leaving the owner to arrange repairs to the plasterboard shaft and paint. Put the quotes side by side and mark three lines:

  • Outside: What stays, what comes out, and who supplies the flashing?
  • Inside: Will the existing lining and blind remain usable? Who makes good any disturbed surfaces?
  • If the frame cannot stay: Who will show you the finding, price the alternative and obtain approval before proceeding?

When requesting a steel roof installation quote, name the room as well as the skylight. “Keep the daylight above the kitchen table and include reinstating the painted ceiling” describes the result you want far better than “one skylight”. Let the site assessment settle how to achieve it.

References

Plan your next step

Residential roofing & replacement →Discuss your roofing project

Keep reading